Skip to main content

5 Best Horror and Dark Shows Like American Horror Story

Discover a curated list of horror and dark comedy series recommended for fans of American Horror Story, including Scream Queens, Sabrina, Hannibal, and The Terror on streaming platforms.

AI-written
Inewgen
25 Sep 2026Source: Lifehacker3 min read (0 views)
Share
5 Best Horror and Dark Shows Like American Horror Story

Stock photo for illustration only, not from the actual event

Font size
  • Explore a curated selection of alternative TV shows tailored for fans of American Horror Story
  • Includes notable recommendations such as Scream Queens, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, Hannibal, and The Terror
  • Provides streaming platform availability details for Hulu, Netflix, and Prime Video

For viewers who have thoroughly enjoyed the thrilling and eerie anthology stylings of American Horror Story and are searching for their next binge-watch, Lifehacker writer Ross Johnson has put together a curated recommendation list capturing a similar atmospheric vibe.

The first recommendation is Scream Queens, another eccentric creation by Ryan Murphy that leans heavily into overt satire while keeping the boundary between comedy and horror razor-thin. The series features an all-star cast including Emma Roberts, Ariana Grande, Billie Lourd, and Abigail Breslin as sorority sisters battling a vicious dean played by Jamie Lee Curtis and a serial killer disguised as their school Red Devil mascot. You can stream it on Hulu.

dark gothic television series scene

Stock photo for illustration only, not from the actual event

Next up is Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, which fits well for fans of American Horror Story: Coven. This dark adaptation of the Archie character stars Kiernan Shipka as Sabrina Spellman, a teenage witch torn between signing Satan's book to become a full witch or remaining in high school with human friends, amidst heavy themes of cannibalism and blood rituals. It is available to stream on Netflix.

Never miss the latest news?

Subscribe to get news summaries by email - not often enough to be annoying.

โฆษณา

Dark fantasy and horror-comedy series that balance chilling scares with eccentric humor often rely on distinct visual flair and complex character dynamics. Transitioning to shows like Scream Queens or Hannibal after watching American Horror Story allows viewers to explore similar high-concept storytelling and stylistic cinematography.

Another strong recommendation is Hannibal, a twisted adaptation of Thomas Harris novels showrun by Bryan Fuller of Pushing Daisies. The series features stunning Grand Guignol visuals and stars Mads Mikkelsen as Dr. Hannibal Lecter alongside Hugh Dancy as profiler Will Graham, maintaining such a dedicated cult following that revival talks continue over a decade later on Prime Video and Netflix.

Finally, The Terror offers an anthology format focusing on historical horrors surpassing the supernatural. Season one adapts Dan Simmons' novel about the ice-trapped ships Erebus and Terror, season two explores World War II internment in California, and the latest installment stars Dan Stevens as a man involuntarily committed to a psychiatric facility, all streaming via AMC+ and Shudder.

Source: Lifehacker

Comments

Leave a Comment
0/2000

Found something wrong in this article? Report an issue with this article